Originally Posted on

I want to take a moment to state my current beliefs about finances and my financial goals for 2020. However, every time I go to write that post, I can’t seem to get Ramit Sethi‘s voice out of my head. This annoys me because the author of the brazenly titled I Will Teach You to Be Rich very clearly has financial goals (to get rich) which I have recently begun to realize are not my goals. However, Sethi gave a powerful keynote speech at FinCon19 about knowing your voice and message, being unapologetically committed to your viewpoint, and free of guilt about spending (money or time) on your values. I may not want to be rich, but I do want to have a clearer point of view for this blog.
If I asked you right now, “What is your point of view?” would you have an answer?
Ramit Sethi, FinCon19 keynote speech
Writing is my favorite way to process the world and connect with others, so I’ve been blogging in some form or another off and on over the last 20 years, but since becoming a mother (and especially in the several year period of grief following the loss of my dad), I’ve struggled with the shift in my voice and my identity. I began Free, Fun, Family primarily as a way to share the journey of our family as we try to live a life of freedom and joy in a world that seems designed to keep us all perpetually dissatisfied and wanting. (Yay, capitalism?)
Because we had a mountain of debt in 2018 that was interfering with our family’s ability to live in the way that we wanted, the blog has also served as a way to keep me accountable to meeting our financial goals. We’ve done some of the hard work to correct our habits, and we will eventually get out from under this debt (although some days it’s harder to believe than others).
I have come to realize, however, that my values for personal finance were not clearly articulated. So what is my point of view about personal finance?
- I believe debt can be a useful tool, but that the deregulation of the banking and loans industry has lead to predatory lending and unnecessary inflation of living standards that exploits human nature and is harming the American public. Because I have the ability and privilege to understand some of the harmful practices of lending institutions, I have sometimes used these tools to save money (such as student loans, introductory offers, mortgages, and balance transfers). However, my participation in these practices does not sit well with my ethics any more. While I will continue to use some of these consumer tools to pay off the debt I have incurred, I will be more mindful about how my use of them to my family’s advantage is harming others without the same privilege. I will be more vocal in speaking out about the harms of such practices and the need for regulations to protect consumers from the financial industry.
- I believe that people have a personal responsibility to manage their finances, but that the economic conditions of American capitalism devastate families at a faster pace than American self-reliance can keep up. I value frugality and living within your means. Unfortunately, the way healthcare and public education funding works in this country leaves far too many families with choices not about whether or not to forgo the daily $4 luxury coffee (thanks, latte factor, which is not AT ALL gendered…), but rather with the choice of taking on an additional $150,000 in mortgage to access a school district that aligns with their children’s needs or pay $2000 for a live-saving medication not fully covered by their insurance. I’m also not a fan of dumping the responsibility of investing and saving for retirement onto individuals (re: the move from defined pensions to 401ks).
- I believe that talking honestly about our relationship with money, consumption, income, and wealth can help undo harmful narratives and expose the exploitative practices we need to change. One of my favorite aspects of being part of the personal finance blogging community is coming across articles where individuals confront the racial wealth gap and the gender wage gap in ways that are not just academic. I am committing to continuing to contribute my own story to this narrative by talking about things like immigration policy and real-life financial decisions.
- (Here’s the most controversial one, friends): I believe that material success is much, much more determined by external, random factors (parental income, location of birth, health conditions, etc.) than personal qualities, although personal improvements and education can help individuals rise to their most glorious humanity. People are incredible and wonderful–they work so hard and achieve so much. I’m not saying they don’t. Just that our tendency to look at “success stories” makes us think there is something personal and easily replicable about the achievements of people like Bill Gates, Warren Buffett, and Oprah. There are at least 10,000 equally spectacular and intelligent hard-working humans who did most of the same things as these household names that didn’t “make it” for each one of these superstars. Imagine if our world allowed for the possibility of 10,000 of each of them instead of a winner-takes-all competition to the “top”? (For more about this, I recommend Malcolm Gladwell’s Outliers.)
- Humans are capable of creating a more just world, and are obligated to do so. I’m an optimist; a “humanist in a captialist world” as a friend once described her husband. We built the systems and institutions that made the world unfair and exploitative. We can change them.
In short, I believe that the world of personal finance is not a just one, but that it’s the one we have, so you have to learn to play. I also believe it’s important to use your wins to fight for a more just world. I’m playing by the rules to get out of my own debt, but if those rules were to change now and become more fair for the world, I would celebrate that progress rather than lament the harms I suffered.
Now that we’re all clear about what we stand for, what are my financial goals for 2020?
- Repair the emergency fund and sinking fund to minimal levels and resume monthly contributions. These were just about wiped out over the last three months for both planned and unplanned expenses. It will mean the debt repayment will slow a lot over the next three months, but having those funds were what enabled us to continue progress instead of going further in debt.
- Reduce total debt by over $15,000. That will include an estimated $7,000 in the debts (mortgage and undergrad student loan at 1.65% interest) not included in our Debt Elimination project, so I guess I’m trying for over $8,000 paid off on the debt freedom thermometer. Woo hoo!
- Improve % of giving by more than 1%. I loved what giving did for my finances and my values last year, and I will continue to grow in this area. I have this as a goal until out of debt when I plan to set it at 10%.
- Declutter 100 items a month from my home. I have struggled with consistent motivation, but I think this is manageable for me this year.
- Mindful consumerism to reduce expenses. Continuing to question my purchases and their impact on the planet and people. This includes an already-begun shopping ban.
Going beyond will include retirement contributions, college savings, and freelance pursuits, but right now I’m dealing with back pain, and we all know that doesn’t make bigger goals easy. I feel these goals are big and yet manageable. I might get more ambitious when I’m not doubled over half the time.
This post, and my philosophical exploration, owe a great deal to the following fellow bloggers and Twitter pals. If you’re in the mood for more thoughtful explorations of personal finance and its intersection with fighting back against harmful institutions, I recommend reading a bit from these folks:
- Matt Lane, who blogged about Personal Finance and Politics
- Tanja Hester, who wrote recently about You’ve saved up for early retirement. Can you help to save the world?
- Penny, who blogged about Why I Still Pick Up Pennies
- the76Kproject, who blogged about What I Learned From A Week Of Reducing My Plastic Use And Trying To Be A More Conscientious Consumer
- GovWorker, who blogged about Finances for a Frugal Family of Five
- StephtheBlogger, who blogged about Pulling Yourself Up by Your Boobstraps
Yes. Yes to all of this. Personal responsibility and choices we make are important. But they don’t happen in a vacuum. And the real world doesn’t fit into the narratives we’re often given. Some in the PF space don’t need health insurance because they workout. Others say that it it is impossible to get ahead in this world so you might as well keep buying all of your subscriptions because what is the point. Thanks for articulating your core beliefs. I think I need to work on doing the same. It’s easier to not do that because you can be a chameleon and blend in with many crowds. Thanks for being bold and standing out.
Thanks for the encouragement. It’s important to do what you can, but please acknowledge that the system is rigged, especially if you are one of the benefactors. Dismissing the very real challenges faced by people is just so last century. Side note: the “I don’t need health insurance because I’m 29 and run marathons” people TERRIFY me.
I’m right there with you on all of these philosophies and I thank you for the perfect quote to link to in a pondering post that I’ve been working on for a few weeks.
I’m doing my best to be a good steward of our money this year and every year, to set ourselves up for the future, and that absolutely includes giving back to help people. No matter how little I had, this was an important tenet. There’s always someone less fortunate we can help at point, or something we can improve, and we can hardly be part of a community if we don’t or won’t see that, IMO.
Glad you found the quote and my philosophies palatable. I hope 2020 is the year more people realize that the “bootstraps” narrative–stripped of all context–is incomplete. I do feel that shift happening in some circles.